Jaeda Tucker: You Are More Than The Game
My softball journey started when I was just 4 years old. By the age of 6 I had already started pitching, and almost immediately, I found success. I was pretty dominant right away. People recognized my talent, celebrated my accomplishments, and began to see my potential, and everyone said that if I kept up the good work, I could play college softball one day!
But as I progressed, so did the expectations. What started as a game I loved slowly became something I felt I had to be perfect at. And somewhere along the way, I became more afraid of failing than excited about succeeding.

The fear of failure followed me everywhere, even before I stepped onto the field. My mind would race through every possible scenario of what could go wrong. What if I walked a batter? What if I gave up a home run? What if I let my team down? What would everyone think?
By the time I stepped onto the mound, I often felt defeated before I had even thrown my first pitch. The mental pressure I carried began to affect my performance. Instead of trusting my abilities and competing freely, I was overthinking everything, every decision, and every pitch. I was no longer pitching with confidence. I was pitching in fear, all while pretending everything was ok.
I found myself often doubting my abilities and questioning everything. Did I still love this game? Was I good enough? Was all of this becoming too much? Was this even worth it?
I recall around the age of 11, during one of my pitching lessons, my trainer asked me a question that I will never forget:
“Who are you pitching for when you step onto that mound?”
They gave me something to hold to represent every person I was trying to please in my head. One cone for each of my coaches, one for each of my family members, one for my teammates, and one for everyone else whose expectations I felt responsible for meeting. Then they asked me to try pitching while holding all those cones.

It sounds simple, but the lesson was powerful. How could I possibly pitch freely, trust myself, and perform at my best while carrying all that extra weight?
That moment has stayed with me throughout my pitching journey; however, I continued to silently carry my anxiety inside, pretending everything was okay for years until, during my sophomore year of high school—one of the biggest recruiting seasons of my college prospect years—this all finally broke through for me.
I walked up to the ball field, and just as I arrived at the field, I began having an anxiety attack. I couldn’t explain at the time what was going on or why; I just knew that I was in a panic. My heart was racing, I had shortness of breath, and I felt uneasy. In my head, all I could think was what would happen if I walked a bunch of batters, gave up a home run, what if I would fail my team, my coach, my family, what if all the college coaches thought I wasn’t any good, and I could literally throw all my dreams of playing college softball away in an instant.
Playing softball in college had always been my dream. But there was a point when that dream began to feel like something I had once hoped for rather than something I could actually achieve. I questioned whether I was good enough and whether the pressure was worth everything I was putting myself through.
I realized I wasn’t playing for me anymore. I wasn’t having fun. I had allowed the expectations surrounding my performance to take away the joy that made me fall in love with softball in the first place.
Then everything began to change when I realized I didn’t have to carry that weight alone.

I was fortunate to have an incredible coach and mentor who recognized that what I was experiencing was bigger than softball. She helped me understand that I wasn’t alone in these feelings. Other athletes, including people I looked up to, had experienced similar struggles. For the first time, I began to understand and accept that mental health and performance challenges did not make me weak, and they certainly did not make me any less of an athlete or a pitcher. She also recommended that I start journaling and take deep breaths to release any anxiety while pitching.
So, I started journaling and being honest with myself about what I was feeling instead of pretending everything was okay. I had to acknowledge that I had been constantly trying to please everyone around me, and always have. I was so worried about disappointing my coaches, teammates, family, and the people who believed in me that I had forgotten the person who mattered most in that equation: myself. And while on that mound, I started taking those deep breaths to remind myself I can, and I am. I also had some accountability teammates; when they saw me start to get frazzled, they would call time and take that deep breath with me to help me know I am not alone.
I also made the decision to seek help from a mental health and performance counselor. That experience also helped change my perspective. I learned how to talk through my emotions, recognize my anxiety, and understand that my performance did not determine my worth.

I began learning one of the most important lessons of my athletic career: I am MORE than an athlete, and more than just a pitcher.
My ERA does not define me. My strikeouts do not define me. My wins and losses do not define me. One bad outing does not erase years of hard work, and one great performance does not make me more valuable as a person.
I had to learn to love myself outside of softball. I had to give myself permission to make mistakes, learn, grow, and compete without carrying the weight of the world on every pitch. Most importantly, I had to let go of the fear of failure and start trusting myself again. I had to learn to just breathe. Sometimes all it takes is a deep breath and just a moment of belief.
Today, when I step onto the mound, I take that deep breath and remind myself why that younger me started playing this game. I remind myself that I am capable, that I belong, and that I have what it takes to compete. I no longer want to spend my time or energy worrying about what could go wrong. I want to enjoy the opportunity in front of me, play freely, and have fun.
And I am now honored to say that a dream I once questioned whether I would ever achieve has become a reality, and I committed to play softball at the University of Missouri. What makes this accomplishment so meaningful isn’t just the commitment itself. It’s everything I had to overcome mentally and emotionally to get here. It’s the anxiety attacks, the self-doubt, the moments I questioned whether I was good enough, and the days I almost allowed the fear of failure to take away the game that made me happy and that I loved!

This journey has taught me that achieving a dream is about so much more than the destination. It’s also about WHO you become along the way. Softball has challenged me, strengthened me, introduced me to incredible people, and helped shape the person I am becoming. It has taught me discipline, resilience, accountability, and the importance of having a strong support system. But most importantly, it has taught me that softball is a part of my life, not my identity.
To the athlete who feels the pressure to be perfect, who sits in the car before a game fighting back anxiety, who questions whether they are good enough, or who feels like one bad performance means they’ve failed, YOU ARE NOT ALONE!
You are allowed to struggle. You are allowed to ask for help. You are allowed to have bad days, make mistakes, and still believe in and accomplish your dreams. Don’t let the fear of failing take away the joy of doing something you love. You cannot play freely when you’re constantly worried about meeting everyone else’s expectations. At some point, you too have to put the cones down and remember who you are playing for in the first place. Your performance is something you do, NOT who you are.
This little girl who started playing softball at four years old, has grown into learning to embrace her challenges, believe in herself, and understand that she is enough, regardless of what happens on that field. I no longer step onto the mound feeling like I have something to prove. I step onto it knowing how hard I’ve worked, trusting the person I’ve become, and remembering why I fell in love with this game in the first place. I am ready to play free, embrace the journey, and enjoy every single pitch.
At the end of the day, I am more than the game and so much more than just a pitcher!



